Stone Cottage Home

Clear or Cluttered?

When it comes to creating a welcoming home, there seem to be two camps of thought. Some believe beauty lies in abundance, that the layers of books, baskets, and found objects make a room come alive. Others prefer the calm of simplicity, where each object has its place and purpose. Both approaches can create comfort, …

Clear or Cluttered?

When it comes to creating a welcoming home, there seem to be two camps of thought. Some believe beauty lies in abundance, that the layers of books, baskets, and found objects make a room come alive. Others prefer the calm of simplicity, where each object has its place and purpose. Both approaches can create comfort, but they speak to very different personalities.

The first approach celebrates individual personality and charm. Designer Rita Konig captures this spirit perfectly, seeing rooms as a reflection of life and memory. “I’m like a magpie. There are too many things that I like. Too many things that I want in a room, that I can’t live without.” — Rita Konig

British designer Penny Morrison adds another layer to this idea, noting that “rooms that may look cluttered when photographed feel entirely different in person.” This sentiment reminds us that warmth is often found in using your home, in the scattered belongings that tell the story of who we are and what we love.

Minimalism, on the other hand, carries its own quiet appeal. It is sleek, ordered, and serene. The open surfaces and clean lines can feel peaceful after a busy day, though it can sometimes seem difficult to achieve or sustain. For many, this kind of minimalism feels more formal than lived-in, beautiful yet distant.

Somewhere between the two lies what author Myquillyn Smith calls “cozy minimalism. She encourages us to keep only what truly adds beauty or function to our space, creating a home that feels calm but still deeply personal. It is not about having less for its own sake, but about making room for what matters most.

In these two kitchen pictures one may notice, first, that our previous kitchen and our current kitchen are very similar. Secondly, one may notice that while there are decorative objects on both the walls and the countertops, there are large stretches of clear surfaces. Our kitchen is very hard-working and we need to be able to get in there and cook without moving, or working around clutter. On the other hand, I want this space to be beautiful. By decorating, primarily, vertically we’ve been able to find that perfect form & function balance.

Perhaps the most welcoming homes are those that find balance. A shelf filled with beloved books beside a clear tabletop. A favorite painting hung above a simple chair. A room that feels layered, yet easy to breathe in. Because in the end, the most inviting spaces are not defined by how much or how little they hold, but by the sense of peace they offer to those who wish to use them.

Until next time, take care,

Rachel

Join the conversation

  1. Melanie Fay January 6, 2026

    Hope you are having a happy New Year….I agree with you about a photograph showing how crowded something really is rather than just looking at it in person. Also, I have so many favorite things I feel the need to have on display. I will take into consideration to show less on table tops and rotate my pretties…as we do with seasonal decorations. Perhaps breathing will be easier! This year I just might experience “cozy minimalism”……I just might be surprised. All the best….Melanie Fay

    1. Rachel Stone January 6, 2026

      I hope your New Year is off to a great start, as well, Miss Melanie,
      Yes, you might just be surprised at how much you like “cozy minimalism!”

  2. Katherine Richardson January 6, 2026

    I like the phrase “cozy minimalism.” I have found myself moving toward the cozy minimalism and now I have the term which suits my mood. Thanks.

    1. Rachel Stone January 6, 2026

      Absolutely! There is actually an entire book on the subject…
      Have a lovely New Year!

  3. Janet January 6, 2026

    I recently heard the term cozy minimalism and realized that that is what I am going for! I think a lot of people, like me, have become enamored of the decluttering craze on youtube, but still love their treasures. I am working on reaching a balance, as you said. Have sold a lot on facebook, and donated a lot more. I am also calling this “downsizing in place” (similar to “aging in place”). I am sure we would love more discussions on this from you!

    1. Rachel Stone January 6, 2026

      Yes!
      Once you get the concept, the phrase “cozy minimalism” is quite handy. Decluttering and organizing have become a way of life for us. It is freeing and the side benefits of entertaining more often and having a home that is so much easier to clean means I’ll never go back!

  4. Marlene January 6, 2026

    I don’t know which I am, I just decorate with things I love. Some areas may be cluttered and others not so much. I love reading all your ideas and the way you place them. Thanks and pray you are having a great new year.

    1. Rachel Stone January 6, 2026

      Thank you for reading the post and giving the ideas consideration. May you have a lovely New Year!

  5. Kathy January 6, 2026

    Yes! Cozy minimalism is how I would describe my home. I have many things I love. Switching things out is how I can accomplish this. I do purge every year asking if an object serves a purpose or simply brings me joy.

    1. Rachel Stone January 6, 2026

      Sounds like a great plan, Miss Kathy!

  6. Dana January 13, 2026

    Thank you for this. Please do more on cozy minimalism as your take on it is so very helpful. I am kind of torn between cozy cottage style and a clean uncluttered look. I’ve been searching for a balance and you are definitely an inspiration. I think of my style as: cozy, but not cluttered; quaint and charming, but not cutesy; and pretty, but not fancy. God bless you!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Comments are read & approved before they appear.

Letters from the Cottage

A personal weekly letter from the Stone Cottage Home, sharing subscriber-first updates, the rooms & home projects we’re working on, plus our latest interior design musings, delivered every Tuesday morning.

Subscribe